Should you use sanitizer or just plain soap and water?

MAYO CLINIC NEWS
NETWORK (TNS)

According to the Centers for Disease Control and prevention, frequent hand washing is the No. 1 way to prevent the spread of infections. But what kind of soap is appropriate? And what about using hand sanitizers?

Kindergarten teacher Courtney Dohman dishes out a squirt of hand sanitizer to students at Holmes elementary School in Oak Park, Illinois, in September 2009. Schools across the U.S. used sanitizers to help fight the swine flu. (CHUCK BERMAN/CHICAGO TRIBUNE/TNS)
Kindergarten teacher Courtney Dohman dishes out a squirt of hand sanitizer to students at Holmes elementary School in Oak Park, Illinois, in September 2009. Schools across the U.S. used sanitizers to help fight the swine flu.
(CHUCK BERMAN/CHICAGO TRIBUNE/TNS)

Why not antibacterial soap?
“The simple answer is that plain soap and running water coupled with good technique are just as good against common childhood respiratory and stomach viruses and bacteria as antibacterial soap.

Plain soap doesn’t induce the risk of creating resistant organisms, according to a recent review article published by Infectious Diseases Society of America,” said Dr. Peggy Decker, a Mayo Clinic Health System pediatrician.

Health care settings, such as hospitals and clinics, may have different recommendations.

Comprehensive information is available from the Centers for Disease Control.

Safety of sanitizers
Because of the high alcohol content, there are several safety concerns with hand sanitizer. Kids shouldn’t use it unsupervised. Some experts recommend limiting how often young children use hand sanitizer, and it should not be used on children under 2 years of age. Alcohol is flammable so sanitizer needs to be stored safely away from flames and heat sources. There are strict guidelines for placement in schools and daycare centers to reduce the risk of fire.

“Due to high alcohol content in hand sanitizer, alcohol poisoning and intoxication is possible if a large amount is absorbed by drinking, using on damaged skin or using on babies who don’t have a fully developed skin barrier. Because the alcohol concentration is high — more than hard liquor — and young kids have a low body weight, prevention of accidental or purposeful ingestion is important,” Decker explained.

Supervision of hand sanitizer use (dime-size amount is all that’s needed) and safe storage are important. If accidental ingestion of more than one squirt of hand sanitizer occurs, call the poison control center at 1-800-222-1222.

Wash hands often
Despite the risks of alcohol-based hand sanitizers, children should avoid alcohol-free hand sanitizer due to concerns about resistant organisms with the antibacterial agents benzalkonium chloride and the possible toxic degradation products of triclosan.

“Remember, frequent hand washing keeps germs at bay and can go a long way in protecting your child from viruses and bacteria,” added Decker. “By teaching your child the importance of hand hygiene and how to properly clean their hands, you can help them establish healthy habits that will last a lifetime.”

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here